Back to the Archive: The Silly Season? (26 July 2011)
In 2011, I was already worrying about the decline of news and the influence of the algorithm.
"...we are content to be the recipients of a diet of drivel and inconsequence while our faith in others, ourselves, in politics and public life fades away. We will be in dangerous, dangerous territory if that is the path we take."
Text first published on DeAlign (links added).
Normally at this time of year, we enter what broadcasters and journalists like to call the news ‘silly season’. I have always disliked this phrase, implying as it does, that there is no news to be had unless the Mother of All Parliaments is sitting.
But these last few weeks have felt far from silly. Although the News of the World scandal dominated headlines, the much smaller type contained stories of famine in East Africa, the underhand privatisation of the NHS and other public services, a notable Eurozone crisis and the debt ceiling stand-off in the United States.
Then, over the weekend, we were overwhelmed by the abhorrent slaughter of a group of politically engaged young people on the island of Utøya.
Not silly at all.
But with all this news to choose from and particularly with one story going right to the heart of press freedom and the diversity of viewpoints on offer from the media, surely now is the time to ask ourselves, do we get the news we want or the news we’re given? Or, are we so used to what we get that we don’t know what we want? Or, is it just easier not to hear about the hard, intractable, distressing, inhuman things that happen to other people thousands of miles away?
You might imagine, and it has been argued, that the rise of the internet has made us more informed about the world than ever before, that the internet has democratised news and made us more powerful citizens as a result. Instead, an algorithm determines the content of your Google search, based on your location, what Google already knows about your preferred sites and other information it may have gathered about you from other sources. Facebook only shows you output from the friends you talk to most, sending you spiralling into a reinforced cycle of social interaction with your most active friends.
If you get your news from Twitter, you have already determined your sources through the people you follow. Most of us follow other like-minded people, those that share our views, values and interests. Is your twitterfeed a hotbed of diverse opinion or does it simply reflect back your own world view?
Of course this is completely understandable. We’ve been doing it with newspapers for years. Few of us would choose to read a newspaper replete with views in total opposition to our own or buy several newspapers each day for a range of views. Perhaps here the internet wins an element of the debate, many of us now scan multiple newspaper websites for sources of news.
There are other consequences to the competition to traditional news sources that the internet provides, two of which are a particular concern. Jon Slattery of MediaBriefing.com has written an excellent piece on the decline of news agencies and reduction in professional journalists over the last ten years. For decades, much news gathering has been delivered by news agencies - large international agencies like Associated Press and regional and local agencies in Britain. These agencies provided the legwork and investigation that were the source for breaking stories and their work would appear in the national newspapers. Since the internet has become a source of news itself and news bloggers have become more active, news agency work looks expensive to the national newspapers and the agencies are starting to close down as the papers drop the rates they are prepared to pay for stories.
The result is a smaller supply of independent, professionally produced news and instead a recycling of stories from newspapers to the internet and vice versa, often without crediting the original source. Plagiarism is on the rise.
The second critical change has been the reduction in overseas news bureaux run by the biggest broadcasters and newspapers. Thirty years ago, correspondents were bringing us news from all parts of the world, writing incredible stories, with a deep, local perspective, that helped us understand the political and human struggles and successes of our fellow men and women. These days there are far fewer international correspondents and we are the poorer for it.
Imagine a world which will never have another Alistair Cooke. There was a man who each week delivered a scalpel-sharp assessment of American politics, written from a trans-Atlantic perspective but with a great sense of his British audience. That precision, that local knowledge and deep appreciation is gone and our capacity to truly understand and empathise with our international neighbours is gone with it.
The gap in international news is filled far more cheaply by celebrity and gossip. We have always had scandal-magazines and gossip disguised as news. The News of the World was famous for it long before Murdoch turned up with his chequebook. What’s changed is that the most frivolous aspects of the lives of the famous and infamous, our musicians, sports stars, politicians and other public figures, are now the overwhelming subject matter of so many of our newspapers and news sources.
Even our most revered broadsheets and still-pioneering investigative journals are not immune from the trickle of news-gossip the population has come to love.
Amy Winehouse died the day after sixty-nine young people were murdered, the day thousands more children in the Horn of Africa were subjected to famine conditions. Even in those news conditions, the tragic death of a single, talented woman, created more print acreage than looked appropriate. In fact, it looked unapologetically over the top.
So, if technology is reducing rather than widening our sources and business models are dictating the breadth of our world view, is it any wonder that we only pay attention to what we are offered? Perhaps these days we don’t even consciously have to hide from the unbearable suffering of others because no one is really trying to tell us about it. And if they do, it’s a reporter flown into a trouble-spot with a flak jacket and an escort, rather than a correspondent who knows the town or the country and its people personally.
The world feels like an increasingly scary and difficult place to many of us, maybe we feel that way because we don’t use our resources to understand it as we used to. Instead we are content to be the recipients of a diet of drivel and inconsequence while our faith in others, ourselves, in politics and public life fades away.
We will be in dangerous, dangerous territory if that is the path we take.