From the Archive: We've Forgotten that the State Belongs to Us

From the Archive: We've Forgotten that the State Belongs to Us
Photo by Hansjörg Keller / Unsplash

First published in March of 2012. With the Coalition government established and austerity on the way, I continue to worry about the deconstruction of the state and public service.


I awake to news that the Chancellor plans to remove national pay agreements for public sector workers. I sigh and conclude that this is the obvious next step for a plan that begins with enabling academies and free schools to pay teachers whatever they like and the outsourcing of health and social services to the likes of Richard Branson’s Virgin Care.

Of course, those of us around local government saw this road helpfully paved by Labour’s 'compact' with the voluntary sector to enable them to deliver public services, including elements of children’s services like leaving care teams, offending schemes and family intervention. It was paved by previous governments too, as cleaning and catering services in hospitals and schools were outsourced to the private sector without looking like wholesale privatisation.

We have been heading to this point for years and it has been right out in the open.

The compact between the Labour government and the voluntary sector changed the shape and motivation of our biggest charities. On the one hand, lucrative government contracts were available to the large organisations to support policy initiatives. I should know, my old post was funded by DCSF for at least two years.  On the other, the big voluntary sector organisations were encouraged to tender for the delivery of public services in the areas of their assumed expertise. The consequence of this was the metamorphosis of campaigning, fundraising organisations who gave a voice to those they represented, into businesses concerned with the next large local authority tender. Some of the biggest children and young people’s charities, for instance,  increased their value and turnover by millions in a small number of years. Not through fundraising but through the acquisition of contracts. Organisations with no previous expertise in a particular type of work with a specific group of young people would tender to deliver statutory or other services to them, simply in order to extend their reach and increase their revenue.

Charities in receipt of public money to deliver services on behalf of the government that pays them, are not good campaigners. Their willingness to speak truth to power is undermined by their reliance on central funding. It is not a virtuous circle.

What was billed as the opportunity for voluntary expertise to be brought into the delivery of services to the vulnerable, created a market within the voluntary sector, competition between previous collaborators and a ‘big dog’ mentality amongst charity leaders who were determined to be the go-to organisation for whatever sector they worked in.

As local government services were outsourced to charities, formerly public sector staff were ‘TUPED’ across to the voluntary sector initially on their normal terms and conditions and eventually to worse pay and fewer days off. At the same time those services, which once were linked through local government to the ballot box, were now managed by contract through the council.  An entirely different kettle of fish.

The experience of the voluntary sector has paved the way for private enterprise to do exactly the same thing to an even greater extent. The whole state is up for grabs and everything any of us who have ever worked in the public sector held dear about our service there, our values and reasons for being there, is meaningless now as public service as a vocation dies out.

Our entire definition of the state is being rewritten. It is cast as an inconvenient expense, something that doesn’t belong to or represent us. Something over which we have little control. Our new path is sold to us as the triumph of the individual, to have our needs met so precisely by markets, by sectors who view us as consumers.

We have forgotten that the state belongs to us. More than that, most of us have lost our access to it. We gaze on our political parties and see a parade of individuals who have walked golden pathways into government and then become indistinguishable from each other. Thatcher’s crushing of the unions was her greatest anti-democratic legacy. She closed the door on power to generations of working people and turned Labour into the party of lawyers and professional political bag-carriers that it is now.

So our public services are now to be sold off and the private sector is queuing up to be the happy recipient of our taxes to deliver them. It’s not to be sniffed at. We must be educated and kept well, that’s not a market that’s going away. No wonder Richard Branson has taken time out of his space explorations to see what profit can be made from child neglect and abuse, as he offers his company as a provider of children’s services in Devon.

Subscribe to Lucy Sweetman

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe